|
R. Lanier Britsch and Terrance
D. Olson, eds., Counseling: A Guide to Helping Others, 2 vols. [Salt Lake
City: Deseret Book Co., 1983-1985], Volume 2 © 2001, Deseret Book, GospeLink
2001, Used by permission
7 Eating Disorders: Anorexia
Nervosa and Bulimia Della Mae
Rasmussen
Billions of dollars are spent by millions of Americans each year in an
unending quest for one thing: slimness. There is a national obsession with
dieting, calorie counting, and beautiful thin models in books and magazines and
on television and billboards. The message bombarding us from every direction
seems to be: if you are thin you will be happy, you will have wonderful
relationships, be admired, and have a fine career, and all your problems will be
solved. Nearly everyone has been on a weight loss diet at one time or another,
and millions of people go from one diet to the next, always hoping for the magic
wand that will produce a beautiful, lean body without too much effort. Even
though we see a great emphasis upon exercising and proper nutrition today, the
most important thing seems to be getting slim rather than maintaining good
health. A person's weight, measurements, and appearance have become too much a
measure of a person's worth.
Most people can go on a diet, go off a diet, overeat one day, and cut down
the next day, managing to stay somewhere within their normal weight range. They
become rather philosophical about never being really thin. With certain people,
however, the desire for thinness eventually takes first place in their lives.
These people suffer from an eating disorder, either anorexia nervosa or bulimia.
They have the distorted belief that the thinner they are, the happier they will
be. In their efforts to achieve happiness and thinness they become involved in
the dangerous behaviors of an eating disorder. These behaviors become a way of
coping with the demands of life. Kim Lampson, one of the most experienced
therapists in the field, states that "the behaviors are like a life
preserver, simultaneously a means of survival and a signal of distress."
Anorexia Nervosa
Anorexia nervosa has sometimes been called the "starving disease."
Historically, a number of cases of anorexia nervosa have been reported, but
until recently it was thought to be rare. In the last fifteen to twenty years
there has been a great increase in diagnosed cases. People are becoming more
aware of the name and the extent of the problem. Perhaps one in every one
hundred or two hundred white females between the ages of twelve and eighteen may
suffer from anorexia. Between 90 and 95 percent of those who have the disorder
are female. This may be the result of the greater cultural emphasis on the
physical attractiveness expected of females.
The age of onset is usually early to late adolescence. Medically, the
diagnosis is made for anorexia nervosa when the following conditions are
present:
1. An intense fear of becoming obese that does not diminish as weight loss
progresses. Severe weight loss is the obvious symptom of anorexia nervosa.
The person often suffers from dangerous physical and psychological symptoms, yet
she is terrified of gaining weight and would seemingly rather die than get fat.
Typically, the victim of anorexia nervosa rigidly controls her food intake to
the point of self-starvation.
2. Distortion of body image the person claims to "feel fat," even
when emaciated. On a recent television talk show an anorexic girl was being
interviewed. She wore a bikini, and, standing about 5 feet 8 inches tall and
weighing around 85 pounds, was almost skeletal in appearance. The show's host
looked at her and said, "Surely you cannot think of yourself as fat."
She picked at a tiny fold of skin on her abdomen and replied, "Oh, yes, I
am. Look at this!" She was totally unable to see her emaciated body for
what it was.
3. Weight loss of at least 25 percent of normal body weight for age and
height. Anorexic weight loss is generally achieved by self-starvation, but
the anorexic may also use self-induced vomiting, drastic curtailing of fat and
carbohydrate intake, incessant exercise, laxatives and diuretics, diet pills, or
a combination of any of these.
4. Refusal to maintain body weight over a minimal normal weight for age and
height. No amount of coaxing by family and friends can get the anorexic to
eat normally. Even during hospitalization medical personnel often find it
difficult to get an anorexic person to gain weight. During hospitalization one
anorexic would cover herself completely with her stuffed animals at night,
hoping to perspire enough to lose weight.
5. No known physical illness would account for the weight loss.
Amazingly,
the anorexic maybe highly resistant to physical illness and exhibit a high
energy level in an exercise program. For example, one anorexic girl regularly
ran fifteen miles a day while consuming around 300 calories.
Some Characteristics of Anorexic Girls
A common evidence of anorexia nervosa is amenorrhea (the absence or cessation
of menstruation) in females. It occurs in almost every case.
Anorexics fear loss of control, and by rigidly controlling their food intake
they feel they can at least control one area of their lives. An anorexic girl
may spend a great deal of time thinking about and preparing food, and she may
watch her family eat an elaborate meal she has prepared while she eats a piece
of celery, some lettuce, and a glass of water. One anorexic reported that one
apple made her feel as if her stomach would literally burst.
Most people with this disorder steadfastly deny their illness and resist
getting help. They like the feeling of losing weight and resent any interference
from family, friends, or professionals. People who do not know of the problem
will often compliment the person on her weight loss, thus reinforcing the
anorexic behavior, since the motivation behind the refusal of food is the
obsessive fear of weight gain and the accompanying pleasure of weight loss. The
thinner she becomes, the more "special" she feels. Anorexics appear to
be frightened of the demands of adulthood, preferring to remain in their
childhood with an undeveloped body. They show little if any interest in dating
and boyfriends.
Typically, one who develops anorexia will be characterized as a "model
child," one who never gave her family any problems. The girls tend to be
"people pleasers," perfectionistics, overachievers, compulsive, and
self-disciplined. As weight loss continues, a girl's thinking tends to become
more irrational and distorted, caused in great measure by the starvation state
and the malnourishment of the brain.
Physical Abnormalities from Anorexia Nervosa
Some of the physical abnormalities resulting from anorexia nervosa include
the following:
1. Emaciation
2. Amenorrhea (cessation of menstruation)
3. Fine body hair called "lanugo"
4. Stomach distress and intestinal cramps
5. Dry skin
6. Hair loss
7. Yellowish tinge to the skin
8. Low blood pressure
9. Lowered body temperature (the person feels cold all the time)
10. Slowed heart rate
11. Fluid and electrolyte imbalance
Fluid and electrolyte imbalance causes dehydration and potassium deficiency
and is the most serious symptom, resulting in muscle weakness, apathy, mental
confusion, and irregular heartbeat. Death from kidney or heart failure may
result.
Recovery
It is estimated that 50 percent of anorexia sufferers will completely recover
normal weight and eating patterns, and 25 percent will improve but retain
significant eating or weight problems. Mortality rates are estimated to be as
high as 15 to 21 percent. Of those who return to normal weight, from 3 to 50
percent remain amenorrheic. As anorexics recover, most of the abnormalities are
reversed; however, some remain permanent.
It must be remembered that despite the characteristics of anorexia, each
individual is unique. Every case must be treated on an individual basis.
Factors in the Development of Anorexia
Some factors in the development of anorexia nervosa include the following:
1. Stressful life situations. Life's demands may appear to be
overwhelming to the anorexic. For example, concern for school achievement,
personal attractiveness, acceptance by friends7 or family conflict may be more
than she can bear. She does not feel adequate to cope with these demands.
2. Perfectionism. The person's need to be perfect is strong. Nothing
is ever good enough. Her initial goal for weight loss may be reached, but she
will think, "I should lose five pounds more, just to be safe." She
thinks in terms of "all or nothing." One slip and all is lost.
3. Ineffective interpersonal relations. The person avoids true
closeness with others because she fears rejection. She does not assert herself
and express her own needs, feelings, and ideas in open communication. She
typically has few close friends.
4. Biological predisposition. There may be a biological predisposition to
anorexia that is related to the functioning of the hypothalamus gland, but it is
still uncertain whether the starvation damages the hypothalamus or a malfunction
of the hypothalamus promotes the development of anorexia nervosa.
5. Family disturbance. There is no typical family from which anorexics
emerge, although they tend to come from families where food and weight have been
focal issues. Excess attention is paid to what people are eating, or perhaps
parents have tried to force people to eat, or not to eat, as the case may be.
One young anorexic told how as a small child she followed her older sister and
her friends around as they constantly discussed how fat they were and what their
newest diet would be.
Families of the anorexic appear most often to be "enmeshed." They
value "rightness" and not being different. They have a high degree of
concern and involvement with each other. They want everyone to think and act in
the same way, and, to avoid conflict, they do not discuss personal needs and
feelings openly. The anorexic child is often involved in parental conflict in
some way and may feel responsible for such conflict because she is not a perfect
daughter. She will often feel guilty and unworthy and attempt to find acceptance
through her achievements and being attractive.
Families of children with eating disorders are not bad families; they are
most often simply families doing the best they know how. They feel great pain
over a daughter's problem. One mother wrote to me as follows:
What It's Like to Be the Mother of an Anorexic Child
While the key word to an anorexic is control, the word that expresses
the feelings of most parents of anorexics is helpless—helplessness,
frustration, anxiety, fear, guilt, and lots of pain. In just a short span of
time, you watch your beautiful, happy, well-adjusted, and successful daughter go
through a frightening metamorphosis. Overnight you seem to be the mother of a
frighteningly thin, unhappy, spiteful, angry, noncommunicative, and very
manipulative individual whom you barely know or recognize.
You feel totally unequipped to deal with, let alone help, this new person in
your home. All of the normal motherly feelings of love, nurturing, and caring
are still there, but where they were welcome before, now they are rejected
suspiciously and angrily. After all, "You are what caused this
problem!" Then come the feelings of guilt, failure, and self-recrimination.
It is not a case of "What did I do to deserve this?" Rather, you start
wondering "What did I do wrong? Why couldn't I be a better mother.?"
Where communication had been pleasant, it now becomes loud and tense on both
sides, if it occurs at all. Then there are the tears. Gallons of tears. In front
of her, in the privacy of your room, in response to a query from a friend about
your daughter. You read all you can find about this illness that previously had
been an unknown word to you. But what you read is of little comfort. In fact, it
can easily have the opposite effect.
You start to feel a real strain in your relationship with your husband as you
invariably disagree on how to relate to your daughter or on what direction to go
to help her get professional help. You turn to what seems to be one of the few
sources of reassurance, friends who have already been through this hell and know
just what you are feeling and just what to say. Through it all, you are scared
to death! And you pray a lot.
Rapid recovery is not to be expected, and, in severe cases, hospitalization
is necessary to prevent death by starvation or one of the other severe symptoms.
The victims cling tenaciously to their distorted beliefs, and I strongly suggest
professional help for the sufferer and her family. Those professionals involved
should be a medical doctor for a thorough physical evaluation, a nutritionist
for help with healthy food intake and eating patterns, and a counselor or
psychotherapist to help with emotional needs. These professionals should be
chosen from those who thoroughly understand eating disorders and can offer
continuing assistance. The victim is not helped by the admonition "Now you
just go home and put on some weight, my dear."
Signs to Watch For
If you suspect that someone is beginning to suffer from anorexia, you should
watch for these signs:
1. Dieting excessively; refusing to eat, to the point of self-starvation.
2. Claiming to "feel fat" when the person is actually normal weight
or underweight.
3. Paying excessive attention to food, calories, nutrition, and cooking.
4. Refusing to eat but often watching others eat.
5. Excessive exercising, overactivity.
6. Loss of menstrual period.
7. Spending much time in the bathroom, perhaps vomiting in secret.
8. Obsessive or unusual eating behavior, such as cutting up food into tiny
bits and arranging them on the plate in ritualistic patterns.
9. Complaining of a "bloated feeling" after eating small or normal
amounts of food.
10. Eating in binges (possibly in the middle of the night), followed by
purging, overexercising, or fasting.
11. Use of laxatives, vomiting, or diuretics to control weight.
12. Constantly weighing herself.
Some few anorexics are not starvers but bingers. This group appears to have
several characteristics more like the eating disorder of bulimia than the
anorexic who controls her weight in ways other than purging.
Bulimia
Bulimia is an eating disorder in which the person binges on huge quantities
of food, usually high-calorie foods and sweets, and then purges the food through
self-induced vomiting or the use of large amounts of laxatives and diuretics.
The word bulimia is derived from the Greek and literally means "ox
hunger." Like anorexia, bulimia often begins as the result of dieting. The
person tries to lose weight but still eats large quantities of food. She panics
over her overeating and uses purging to prevent weight gain. Eventually the
behavior becomes compulsive. It is difficult for people who have never
experienced this horrible, out-of-control feeling to understand it. Since the
person feels guilty and embarrassed, she is usually secretive about her behavior
and may suffer from bulimia for several years before seeking help. Bulimics are
usually of normal weight or perhaps slightly overweight, although one bulimic of
record weighed almost three hundred pounds!
Bulimia usually starts in the late teens or early twenties, but it varies
from early teens to much later ages. The incidence is growing and is of almost
epidemic proportions. According to some experts, between 20 and 30 percent of
college-age students are involved in bulimic behaviors. The incidence is growing
and is of near-epidemic proportions. As with anorexia, probably over 90 percent
of the victims are female. Recently, however, reports show that the number of
males appears to be increasing.
A bulimic is usually similar in many ways to an anorexic in her behavior and
attitudes, but she may differ in the following ways:
1. Food becomes an obsession and an addiction.
2. She wants to be attractive to men and to please them, and she is
interested in having boyfriends.
3. She may have spent her life trying to please her father through her
accomplishments and her beauty.
4. She is more socially skilled.
5. She will not lose a great deal of weight.
6. She may or may not lose her menstrual periods, but she may have
irregularities.
7. Her body image is probably not distorted.
8. She recognizes that her eating behavior is abnormal.
9. Her eating is more impulsive, and thus less controlled
10. She may use drugs and alcohol more often.
11. She eats huge amounts of food and then purges the food through
self-induced vomiting or taking large amounts of laxatives or diuretics.
12. She may feel guilty and depressed when she falls short of expectations.
Many bulimics report that as their binge-purge behavior becomes a compulsion,
they spend almost every waking hour thinking about food—how to get it, how to
eat it without being detected, and how to get rid of it once it is consumed.
Some bulimics binge and vomit many times a day, some once or twice a week. The
practice becomes bulimic when it can no longer be controlled. Although generally
bulimics have high moral principles, they sometimes lie, hide, and even steal to
support their food habits. Expenditures of $100 a week are fairly common, with
one bulimic telling of a habit amounting to $100 a day. One young woman reported
that she spent every noon hour driving from one fast-food place to another,
gorging as she drove, and then using up to seventy-five laxative tablets to
purge. A person would die from this dosage if her tolerance had not been built
up over time. Ironically, it has been estimated that only about 12 percent of
the calories consumed are purged by the use of laxatives. It is also clear that
no method of purging rids the body of all the calories taken in binges, since
bulimics seldom achieve thinness with their purging methods. The binge-purge
behaviors themselves are reinforcing, however, because they relieve the anxiety
suffered by the victim.
Physical Abnormalities Resulting from Bulimia
Bulimia is a serious disorder and may result in lasting physical effects and
even death. There may be extensive erosion of tooth enamel from the stomach
acid. The habitual use of vomiting or laxatives can cause permanent kidney
damage. Losing large amounts of body fluids may result in kidney failure. The
salivary glands often become swollen, giving the chipmunk-like look of some
bulimics. Sometimes the stomach will rupture or develop ulcers, and the
esophagus may be punctured. As with anorexia, the electrolyte balance is thrown
off, and the potassium level may be severely depleted, causing heart
difficulties.
Binging and purging rewards the sufferer because it fills up her time so that
she can avoid facing the demands of life. The behavior, therefore, becomes
relaxing and reinforcing.
A bulimic has difficulty expressing her true feelings, which become so
distorted that she does not recognize them for what they are but feels them as
hunger. Her attention and energy are taken up with the binge-purge activities.
As with anorexia nervosa, there is no quick fix for curing bulimia. The
bulimic, being caught up in her "all or nothing at all" thinking, may
declare, "I am going to recover quickly and completely. Fast is best."
But eating disorders are among the most difficult problems to deal with for the
individual, for the family, for school and church leaders, and for professional
counselors.
Treatment for Eating Disorders
Kim Lampson, a recovered anorexic-bulimic who has worked with hundreds of
victims, says, "Before 'curing', a foundation must be laid for personal
growth, self-esteem, quality relationships, and the ability to live each day. It
is essential for all involved to realize that the disorders, are not a food
problem, but a self-esteem problem."
Recovery requires personal choice and perseverance. The person must decide to
get well. But much support is needed once the person wants to stop her
destructive behavior. The cooperation of the individual, the family, school and
church leaders, counselors, or psychotherapists is needed. Those affected by the
person and her behavior also need support in dealing with the problem. They
should remember that pressure to change immediately is premature and will only
force the sufferer deeper into her behavior.
In order to recover, the person suffering from anorexia nervosa or bulimia
needs the following:
1. Education about nutritional requirements of the body and the adverse
physical effects of starving, hinging, vomiting, and the use of laxatives and
diuretics.
2. Knowledge about her disorder. She needs to be able to discuss her fears
and anxieties without fear of rejection or ridicule. If there are therapy groups
nearby it may be beneficial for her to join one. This is true particularly of
bulimics. Anorexics often do better in individual therapy.
3. To be able to recognize her distorted thinking. She may use all-or-nothing
thinking: "If I can't do it perfectly, I'm a total failure." She may
keep up a constant stream of negative self-talk: "I am stupid."
"I always blow it." "I'm worthless." Perhaps she believes
that she knows what other people are thinking about her: "They think I'm a
loser." She may live by her feelings, acting according to her feelings
without thinking things out. Or she may fill her life with "shoulds"
and "oughts," expecting perfect compliance with her unrealistic ideals
and then feeling guilty because she can't measure up.
4. Unconditional love with no pressure to change immediately. She must be
convinced that she has worth; then she can listen to the truth about herself and
her relationships with other people and with food. She needs help from people
who understand her disorder. Also, she may feel so guilty and unworthy
that she won't look to God for help. Care and acceptance from those around her
will help her pray again.
5. To deal with her perfectionism. She wants to recover quickly and
perfectly. But she must learn to accept two steps forward and one step back.
Part of recovery is to realize she can't do things perfectly. She must give
herself permission to fail and be imperfect. Kim Lampson puts it this way:
"Anything worth doing is worth doing poorly, and with practice it gets
better!"
Patience is essential. She can practice saying, "It is okay to fail. It
is an opportunity to learn rather than an opportunity to punish myself." A
setback then becomes a learning experience, not a disaster.
6. To learn and use assertiveness and communication skills. She can practice
the honest expression of her feelings. She should be encouraged to tell others
her needs and feelings directly in a loving way. Most victims of eating
disorders are afraid to do this because they believe they will say the wrong
thing, cause conflict, and lose approval and love. One recovered bulimic said,
"I could never express myself. Everything was all closed up inside of me.
If I stood up for my rights, I thought others would be unhappy with me, and I
couldn't stand anyone being displeased with what I said or did. Obsession with
food helped me survive. It was a way to escape from the world. By focusing on
eating and purging I didn't have to think about my poor relationships or
anything else."
The sufferer must understand her right to be treated with respect, to have
and express personal feelings and opinions, to be listened to and taken
seriously, to say no without feeling guilty, to ask for what she wants, to make
mistakes, and to make choices based on rational thinking.
She must realize that she is not responsible for the feelings of others. They
have their own rights and the power to make choices just as she does. She can be
direct and honest and behave appropriately. She can show a genuine concern for
the rights of others and their feelings as well as her own. Her assertiveness
will not drive people away but will enrich her relationships with others. She
can express her love and care for others without fear. She can disagree with
someone and be close at the same time. This knowledge is crucial. There is no
cure, according to Lampson, until a person can honestly express feelings in ways
that bring about closeness rather than distance.
7. A feeling of self-worth. A feeling of self-worth is enhanced by people
around the sufferer who give her unconditional love without expecting perfection
or superior achievement or anything more than allowing her to be herself. She
has intrinsic worth as a human being, regardless of her accomplishments. What
she is is more important than what she does or how she looks. Is it more
important to be remembered for clothes, grade-point average, thin body, musical
or sports ability, and a pretty face, or for listening ability, compassion,
cheerfulness, kindness, and a love for others? She can practice identifying
qualities that make her special. She might ask someone, "What do you really
appreciate about me?" She can also realize that qualities not so desirable
are also lovable. She does not have to be perfect for people to love her; often
a person's weaknesses and mistakes make them easier to relate to and thus more
lovable. As she shifts from a worldly to a godly perspective, she will look at
the heart instead of the appearance. She can learn to encourage herself in all
her righteous endeavors and to take pride in her character.
8. To give others permission to be imperfect. She should practice loving
others unconditionally in spite of their weaknesses and mistakes. She needs to
listen to their feelings and try to understand them. Especially, she can give
her family permission to be imperfect. They have made mistakes in the past, and
they will again, but they need acceptance too. She can forgive others for their
trespasses against her.
9. The ability to make wise decisions. She can practice developing solutions
for herself. She can be confronted with choices, alternatives, options, and the
consequences of her decisions. Knowledge and practice of problem-solving skills
will help her feel "in charger in her life.
10. To learn effective strategies for dealing with stress and anxiety. Ways
to reduce stress and anxiety include practicing relaxation techniques, talking
out frustrations with a close friend or family member, participating in hobbies
and in sports, helping others, refusing to criticize others or herself, and
trying to be a good friend.
11. To develop normal eating patterns. The person needs to establish eating
habits that are flexible, meet nutritional needs, and maintain a healthy body
weight. She should do away with her list of "forbidden foods." She
should force herself to eat a little of everything without guilt in the presence
of others.
12. To choose her own goals separate from expectations of family and friends.
It's okay if these are different, and it's also okay if they are the same.
13. Accept her body and stop criticizing her own body and the bodies of
others.
14. To think of her struggles as change taking place. She should learn
from the pain and use it to motivate herself rather than trying to avoid it.
Family Issues
Those who attempt to help the child and her family should follow certain
guidelines: Families do not need more guilt and blame. They do need acceptance
and the reassurance that they have probably done the best they could. All family
members could heal hurts by recognizing that no one is perfect. They need to
forgive each other for their real or imagined weaknesses. Families are usually
tired and frightened from the stress of living with a child with an eating
disorder. Family therapy can be helpful if members are available to meet
together. Families can help the sufferer in important ways:
1. Let go. The family should not seek to meet all the social and emotional
needs of the child.
2. Do not try to force a child to eat, or to not eat. Don't watch her eat or
discuss her weight.
3. Never compare the child to anyone else. Help build her sense of
self-worth. Accept her for what she is at this moment in time. Love her
unconditionally, even when she is depressed, irritable, and moody.
4. Don't treat her as if she were "sick" or crazy. Instead,
encourage her independence and her initiative, and let her make decisions for
herself.
5. Insist that she be responsible for her behavior. For example, she should
be required to replace family food supplies or family money she has secretly
used to buy food.
6. Do not center your whole life around the child. She must understand that
the lives of others in the family are not more or less important than her own.
Everyone needs love and attention.
7. Be patient. There is no quick road to recovery. It may take months and
even years of treatment and anxiety.
8. She must do the work for her own recovery. Everyone involved should think
in terms of progress, not perfection.
Fortunately, most anorexics and bulimics do recover, in time. While there are
no "pat answers" in treatment and recovery, skilled counselors are
available and research is going forward. There is hope.
Suggested Readings and Resources
Anorexia Nervosa and Related Eating Disorders, Inc. P.O. Box 5102, Eugene,
Oregon 97405, phone (503) 344-1144.
Bruch, Hilde. The Golden Cage: The Enigma of Anorexia Nervosa. Harvard:
Harvard University Press, 1978.
Chemin, Kim. The Obsession: Reflections on the Tyranny of Slenderness. New
York: Harper and Row, 1982.
Lampson, K. Kim, M.Ed. Lecture given at Brigham Young University, November
1983.
For additional information write to: K. Kim Lampson, M.Ed., Providence
Professional Building, Suite 301, 550 16th Avenue, Seattle, Washington 98122.
National Anorexic Aid Society, Inc. P.O. Box 29461, Columbus, Ohio 43229.
Neuman, Patricia A., Ed.S., and Patricia A. Halvorsen, Ph.D. Anorexia
Nervosa and Bulimia: A Handbook for Counselors and Therapists. New York: Van
Nostrand Reinhold Company, 1983.
Vincent, L.M. Competing with the Sylph: The Pursuit of the Ideal Body
Form. New York: Berkeley Books, 1979.
About the Author
Dr. Della Mae Rasmussen, a counselor at BYU Counseling and Personal Services
for almost two decades, received her bachelor's degree from the University of
Utah and her doctorate in counseling psychology from BYU. She has published in
professional journals as well as in children's literature.
In the Church she has served on the Primary General Board, on the Church
Teacher Development Committee, on a Church writing committee for parent
education, and in many ward and stake callings.
She and her husband, Paul, are the parents of six children.
|
|