|
R. Lanier Britsch and Terrance
D. Olson, eds., Counseling: A Guide to Helping Others, 2 vols. [Salt Lake
City: Deseret Book Co., 1983-1985], Volume 2 © 2001, Deseret Book, GospeLink
2001, Used by permission
22 Fears and Phobias
M. Gawain Wells
All of us have known feelings of fear. Often such feelings teach us of
situations to avoid. We sometimes experience fears about specific objects or
situations where we feel uncomfortable, but such fears do not significantly
interfere with our lives. But phobias, which are excessive and persistent fears,
can seriously interfere with our lives.
Development and Changes of Normal Fears
From birth, infants are startled and cry when exposed to sounds or other
stimuli that are sudden, intense, or novel. Their eyes and mouths open widely
and they reach out to clutch reflexively, even though there maybe nothing to
grasp. Most parents notice how their babies are frightened by loud noises or by
a sense of falling. A mother may feel her baby's startled response to noises
even before its birth, and the family members are amused when the baby tenses
and clings harder when it is being carried down a flight of steps. As the baby
grows, it becomes accustomed to these sensations, and its reactions become less
and less intense. The baby is undergoing a psychological process called habituation
whereby repeated experiences with a stimulus result in paying less attention
to the stimulus.
Research tells us that babies develop the capacity to remember faces very
early. Thus even an infant has the ability to realize that the face of a person
approaching is one it hasn't seen before. Since it has also developed an
emotional bond with the faces it does recognize, the stranger's differentness is
frightening. Most of us have had the experience of having a friend's baby look
at us as if we were the creature from the Black Lagoon, begin crying, and try
desperately to hide itself in Mama's arms. This fear of strangers disappears in
time (usually at about one year) through the same general psychological process,
although some children maintain a general timidity toward strangers throughout
childhood.
From infancy until school age, three categories of fear are present in
children, each becoming less important as the child grows. First is the fear of
noises and sudden movements associated with noise. The sudden, loud noise of
thunder is frightening to most young children. Usually by eight or nine years of
age, children have redefined it as exciting. They've decided it's fun to be
scared . . . a little bit. The second category is fear of strange situations.
Children become frightened when placed in unfamiliar circumstances where they
don't know what to expect and do not have their parents nearby for support.
Examples might be being left alone in a strange room with new people or getting
lost at an amusement park. Thus most moms and dads spend a few weeks in the
Primary nursery while Junior gets acquainted." Fear of the dark also fits
here because, in the absence of visual cues, even one's bedroom can become a
strange place. This fear is often associated with the child's increasing ability
to imagine frightening situations. One man described how important it was as a
young boy for him to get to sleep before his father. His dad snored loudly, and,
even though the boy knew it was his father, he also thought he could see lions
and tigers coming into his room, growling around the posts of his bunkbed.
Imaginary fears can develop from a fear into nightmares, which also occur in the
dark. Thus, a six-year-old girl may not feel comfortable about going to sleep
until she tells her parents, "Goodnight, sweet dreams," which
reassures her that nightmares won't come. Small children often develop innocent
bedtime rituals that help them feel more comfortable with their fears.
Some nightmares become what are called night terrors. Children with night
terrors wake up screaming and crying and can't be comforted. That is because
they are technically still asleep even though their eyes are open and they may
be talking. Once they are gently and truly awakened, the dream is gone. Unlike
most dreams, night terrors occur in the deepest stages of sleep. As a rule,
children don't remember such dreams, and research suggests that they are
harmless to the child (even if harrowing to the parent who thinks his child is
delirious).
The third category of childhood fear is fear of animals. The sudden
approach of a frisky dog or being carried in Daddy's arms up close to a horse's
nose is enough to emotionally undo many young children. The suddenness or
novelty of the experience seems to cause fright. If the animal were to move more
slowly and if the child could choose its own pace for getting acquainted, he
would feel much less afraid.
The intensity of these three kinds of fear generally declines over time,
primarily because of repeated exposure to them and because of the help of caring
adults who reassure the child. However, fears that have been increased by
painful events (such as being afraid of a dog and then being bitten by it) may
require a longer, more careful, repeated exposure and more emotional support if
they are to decrease.
As a child becomes a toddler, he can experience a more serious fear called
separation anxiety. This is an unreasoning fear of being separated from his
parents, and it is often disguised as a fear of going to school, of being afraid
to have his parents go out for an evening or weekend, or persistent worries
about his parents dying. The child may develop headaches, become nauseous and
vomit, or in other ways seem unable to stay in the situation in which he or she
is separated from the parent. Parents can help the child deal with the fear in
three ways: First, it is important that the parent be unafraid of the child's
alarm. This will do much to help the child feel that the problem can be
overcome. Second, it is important that the child be reexposed to the feared
situation with encouragement and support. Sometimes it is necessary to build the
exposure gradually, with increasing amounts of time spent before the parent
returns. In each case the parent and others should continue to express
confidence in the child's ability to overcome the fear. Finally, parents should
look for opportunities to spend time with the child when the fear is not an
issue. Reassured that he or she is loved and that his parents will not leave
permanently— either physically or emotionally—the child's fear will
diminish.
From middle childhood, children can become self-conscious. At this stage
their fears revolve around people— family, friends, classmates, and even
strangers. They fear criticism, rejection, being laughed at, and feeling foolish
or inadequate. Such social fears may be expressed in a fear of public speaking
or of schoolwork.
Like other normal fears, many people overcome these social difficulties by
practice, by repeated exposure to the situation, and by learning confidence in
their abilities. Others, believing that their fears have been confirmed by
disastrous experience, choose to avoid the necessary events that would dispel
their feelings. They may still lead healthy, fulfilled lives, but they will not
enter certain social arenas.
Nearly all of us have experienced unreasonable fears. At different stages of
life, our levels of intellectual and emotional development are associated with
the kinds of fears to which we might have been susceptible. For most of us, the
fear-arousing situations become more manageable and important as we grow through
the influence of repeated exposure, support of family members, and our expanding
capabilities. For some, however, childhood fears (especially those that have
been increased by trauma) become excessive and persistent, limiting activities
and opportunities. Such fears are classified as phobias.
Phobias
A phobia is an abnormal fear. It is characterized by irrationality, feelings
of helplessness, and horror, and it seems to make normal, productive learning
and living impossible. One person with a phobia wrote:
Even walking to class, I was tense, with a feeling of dread knotting my
stomach. I knew it was ridiculous to be so afraid of singing a solo. After all,
the other class members had sung too, for the final exam. In the next twenty
minutes I could find some distraction or logic to reduce my apprehension for a
few moments only to have it rise again, stronger and more unreasoning than
before. As it came my turn, I felt that I just couldn't do it. I wanted to do
anything to escape from the feelings I was experiencing. But somehow any of the
alternatives would be so humiliating. I knew I was trapped.
Standing in front of the class, my knees actually shook so hard I had to hold
on to the piano to make sure I wouldn't fall down. I felt that my face must be
completely drained of any color, and yet I was sweating. As I began, I already
had so much air in my lungs from breathing hard that I could hardly inhale any
more. My heart must have sounded louder than my shaky voice.
I don't know how I ever made it through the song. I was exhausted for the
rest of the day. And now, even months later, I can get tense just watching
someone else sing and thinking of my doing it. As much as I love singing, I
don't think I'll ever be able to perform a solo. I don't ever want to have that
feeling again. I know that it's silly, too, but that's how I feel.
This is a description of what might be called a singing phobia. Often a
person experiencing such anxiety feels nauseous, dizzy, or weak and may have a
sense of choking or suffocation. The heart beats rapidly, the skin perspires,
the pupils are dilated, and the muscles tremble excessively. The extremes of
such feelings are known as panic, and they may occur in a feared situation, real
or imagined. Panic sometimes occurs without warning or apparent cause.
What are the differences between normal and abnormal fears? How do fears that
many people experience and overcome become phobias for others?
One cause may be the intensity of the initial frightening experience. More
important, however, are the reactions of the person to the experience. The
person anticipates other such frightening encounters with increasing anxiety.
For example, a person who fears flying may know that he needs to make a plane
trip in several days. He begins to think about it and becomes nervous. The more
concerned he becomes about his anxiety, the more the emotion increases. The
closer he comes to the time for the flight, the more anxious he is. Then the
final stage comes into focus—an actual decision to avoid flying. Having done
so, the fear diminishes. The person has learned a means of escape, and the
phobia is reinforced. This is what it means to be phobic. The person seems
governed by emotions not appropriate to the real situation but which seem to be
caused by the situation.
Such feelings may even be extended to additional settings, restricting the
person's life and increasing his feelings of desperation about his situation.
Phobic behavior can be expressed in a variety of ways. Some people face the
fearful situation over and over again, and the fear continues to grow. Also,
some people who have animal phobias do not experience "anxiety in
advance" as does the man who must fly or the woman who must sing. They may
not anticipate the appearance of a snake in a park. So their emotions do not
deter them from walking in the park.
Another illustration of a phobia is described as spontaneous panic. Victims
of such panic attacks often report that they are feeling fine, occupied in
normal tasks, when suddenly they feel heart palpitations, difficulty in
breathing, nausea, sometimes an urge to urinate or defecate, and a sense of
imminent death. Without clues to its cause, victims of panic attacks begin to
avoid situations where they might have a reoccurrence. These people are more
afraid of the panic itself than they are of the setting, although the setting
becomes associated with fear and becomes a place to avoid.
The first category is animal phobias. Professionals have categorized phobias
by the nature of the symptoms. These fears are usually of one species of animal,
although occasionally a person will express a fear of many kinds of animals. The
most common are fears of snakes certain insects, spiders, dogs, cats, and birds.
Animal phobias often do not interfere with the lives of their victims as much as
other categories because the victims can live away from the feared species. Of
course, that is not always the case. One woman had such a fear of crickets that
she would not leave her house during the warm months when she might encounter a
cricket.
The second category is social phobias, where the fears are related to
circumstances involving other people. As mentioned earlier, the person usually
fears appearing foolish. Social phobias also range from being highly specific to
general, from stage fright to being afraid to eat with or even talk with people.
Specific phobias constitute the third category. Usually these are fears of
certain circumstances or settings: fear of high places (acrophobia), fear of
closed places (claustrophobia), fear of flying, or fear of driving. About 20
percent of the people seeking phobia treatment have this kind of fear.
The fourth category of phobic symptom is agoraphobia. Agoraphobia literally
means a fear of the marketplace. The symptoms are fears of being away from a
safe person or a safe place. For example, an agoraphobic traveling away from
home may eventually fear any kind of travel. A fear of driving on the highway
leads to fear of driving in town, and then of driving at all. Being afraid of
large department stores gradually spreads to any store, and so on. Being in the
company of a loved one may lessen the fear dramatically, however. Some people
who will not leave their homes alone can go anywhere if a family member or close
friend accompanies them. This is interesting evidence that the situation itself
does not cause the phobia, but this is a point agoraphobias rarely see. If they
were to see it, they wouldn't be phobic anymore. Agoraphobics comprise the most
frequently treated group (60 percent to 75 percent of the total) because their
symptoms so severely limit their opportunities.
Over the past fifteen years, a great deal of clinical and research attention
has been focused on fears and phobias. Several authors have described much of
the apparent fear involved in phobias, especially among agoraphobias, as a
fear of fear. People are accustomed to understanding themselves and having a
greater or lesser degree of control of their feelings. When they encounter a
situation in which they experience extreme fear, one of the most frightening
aspects of that experience is the sense of not being able to control their own
feelings. As you might guess, that is especially the case with those who
experience panic, which seems to "come out of the blue." Thus, what
people are really afraid of is having those uncontrollable feelings again. In
addition, many people are afraid of breaking down in front of other people.
Their nervousness about making fools of themselves increases their anxiety as
well as their attempts to avoid the feared circumstances. A study of fear and
its effects in World War II bomber crews found that the most intense fear
occurred on the first mission. The men reported that they were not so much
afraid of dying as they were of being so frightened that they might behave like
cowards! They were more anxious about controlling themselves than they were
about the object of fear. Once they found that they could perform adequately
under the stress, their fears dropped markedly.
Recently, therapists have noted that panic seems to occur when the person is
in very unpleasant interpersonal interactions in which the person who panics has
strange feelings that he has been unable to express or resolve. Women who felt
trapped in marriages in which they were not happy but which they were afraid to
leave were particularly prone to panic. Most often, they had not connected the
stress in their life situations to the panic attack. In a small percentage of
the cases, panic had been experienced following severe physical stress such as
childbirth, adverse reaction to drugs, hypoglycemia, or a major illness.
Therapists soon found that victims of the physical stress were more rapidly and
successfully treated than those of more chronic, long-term, psychological
stress.
Treatment
The procedure for overcoming phobias is much like that for helping children
overcome their fears—the fearful person needs to understand the nature of the
fear, and especially his fear of fear. He needs to understand that fear, while
certainly not pleasant, is seldom dangerous, and that the way to overcome fear
is to voluntarily enter the feared situation and remain there as long as he can
until the fear dissipates. A lay counselor can explain that fear includes images
that the person helps create. Or, rather than trying to stop the occurrence of
the imagery, a counselor may simply encourage the person to imagine the feared
situation while he is in a safe setting. Perhaps going together to the airport
or piano or highway or a dark room may help. One claustrophobic man entered a
darkened closet with a friend. He felt that he was becoming more and more alone,
that everything was black, and that somehow he was floating away from life in
the midst of his anxiety. When his friend touched his arm and urged him to
remember where he was, he felt his fear immediately lessen, and he remembered
that all he had to do was reach out and open the door to be free of the dark.
Then he noticed for the first time that he could see light coming from
underneath the closet door.
This supported exposure to the feared situation is the best way of overcoming
phobias. In several formal treatment programs, the therapist goes with the
client or with several clients to the actual settings or objects that may be
fearsome. With encouragement and reassurance, the client approaches the feared
situation and then attempts to remain without fear in the presence of the
anxiety-arousing stimulus. Thus, a person who is afraid of heights (the
acrophobia) is asked to climb a stepladder and stay there until the fear
diminishes. The therapist is there encouraging the client, reassuring him,
praising him for his successes, and verbally helping him to remain in the feared
situation.
In some of the programs, the therapist sets up a progression from less
fearful situations to more highly feared circumstances. A program developed by
Bandura and his associates at Stanford University uses the additional benefit of
what is called modeling. Here, the therapist shows the client how to enter the
situation without fear. In the case of a snake phobia, for instance, the
therapist approaches a snake inside a cage. Then he talks to the client and
comes back.
Then the client approaches the snake and talks to the therapist. Next, the
therapist will walk closer to the snake, talking to the client. Then the client
will walk closer to the snake, and so on, until the client can actually stand to
allow the snake to sit on his lap.
In some cases, the therapist finds that the initial fear is too severe for
the person to approach the situation directly. As a preparatory step, the
therapist may teach the client to imagine the events as though he were living
through them. As the client becomes capable of imagining facing the feared
situation and does so without excessive anxiety, then the therapist moves into
live practice.
Often, in combination with such rehearsal or exposure, therapists will teach
clients to talk to themselves, giving themselves encouragement and instruction.
One woman with a severe snake phobia felt that the picture of a snake on a page
began to come alive and move. The therapist helped her by having her say to
herself as she looked at the picture, "Picture on page, picture on
page." This statement helped the client maintain her sense of reality—the
snake is only a picture. Similarly, when a client might be apt to say, "I
could only climb three steps up the ladder today without becoming terribly
frightened. This is terrible! I'll never be able to overcome my fear," the
therapist might help the client to learn to say, "I climbed three steps up
the ladder today. That's better than I've done for a long time. This is a slow
process, but I'm going to make it." Or, instead of thinking, "Well, I
really did well today, but what's going to happen tomorrow? Am I
going to be able to continue my growth?" the client may learn to say,
"Today was great. I really did well, and while I might do better or worse
tomorrow, I'm on my way to overcoming this fear."
Another technique, called flooding, is used less frequently today, but it is
simple to attempt. In this technique, the lay counselor instructs the person to
imagine the feared situation, and then the counselor deliberately describes the
situation in its most fearful terms. The worst possible events that could take
place are described until the client has experienced the fear and its gradual
dissipation. Although live exposure has proven to be more effective, where that
is impractical this process can be helpful.
With complex phobias like agoraphobia, therapists have sometimes found it
useful to refer clients to psychotherapy or marital counseling. Clinicians have
noted that agoraphobics often experience panic as an eruption of emotional
tension felt but not expressed. Spouses and sometimes other members of the
family are asked to participate in the training to learn to understand the
problem, to learn how they can help, and to learn what doesn't help.
Occasionally the couple begins working on deeper relationship problems in the
marriage.
What Can the Lay Counselor Do?
You may be asking, "What can I do to help?" or "How much can I
do?" First, it is important to remember that people with phobias tend to be
very sensitive individuals who want to please other people. They're very
imaginative and usually think about the most terrible possible conclusion to a
fearful situation. Thus, the person who wants to help must be caring and
understanding and able to give reassurance and hope. If the lay counselor
becomes frustrated, feels that the fear is silly, or feels that the person is
weak, then he might be better off not to attempt to help at all. Similarly,
because a phobic seems to know his fear is irrational and yet feels helpless to
change the fear, the counselor needs to understand enough about the phobia to
not take the phobic person's emotional inconsistencies as a personal rejection.
On some days, the person may feel quite confident and make excellent progress.
However, retreats or relapses are typical, and the phobic person needs a great
deal of reassurance. In other words, the counselor must convince the phobic
individual that he is "on his side" and that he will support the
person regardless of his progress.
The psychological elements of agoraphobia and other fears that entail panic
suggest that the nonprofessional should not attempt to treat such difficulties.
However, a concerned, supportive person may help the phobic person with more
specific fears. Helping the person understand his fear, providing encouragement,
and reassuring him during treatment can be most beneficial.
The treatment of fears may be linked with a deeper understanding of our own
spiritual beliefs. After all, fearfulness is a topic discussed in the
scriptures. Most of those references suggest that the unrighteous and the wicked
have every reason to fear God and his judgment; that each of us should prudently
fear God in the sense of being aware of him and desiring in a reverent manner to
live his commandments; and that the Lord has said that as we live his
commandments we have no need to fear other people. Since many people fear
rejection and criticism, the Lord's counsel helps provide comfort: "Fear
not to do good, my sons, for whatsoever ye sow, that shall ye also reap;
therefore if ye sow good ye shall also reap good for your reward. Therefore,
fear not, little flock; do good; let earth and hell combine against you, for if
ye are built upon my rock, they cannot prevail. . . . Look unto me in every
thought; doubt not, fear not." (D&C 6:33-34, 35.) Drawing near to the
Lord has its own calming effect—we are given greater perspective in which to
understand what is really important and what is not. As we live God's
commandments and look toward him and his kingdom, our fear of the responses of
others will diminish. We will become less concerned about criticism and more
confident about the rightness of our acts.
Perhaps, in a sense, some phobias are a crisis of faith after all. Perhaps
God's admonition to look unto him in every thought has even more specific
applicability. As a person approaches a feared situation, holding the image of a
loving God in mind could be very beneficial. Similarly, understanding that we
are God's children and that he wants us to succeed can give us confidence. Many
of us have accomplished very difficult tasks beyond our ordinary skill because
we have done it for God. We wouldn't even have attempted it for ourselves.
Each of us can choose to exercise faith and hope. Indeed, God has commanded
us to hope; therefore it must be within our abilities to choose to see things
hopefully and to exert the energy and faith to overcome our problems and fears
in spite of apparently insurmountable difficulties.
Suggested Readings
Bandura, A., R. W. Jeffery, and E. Gajdos. "Generalizing Change through
Participant Modeling with Self-Directed Mastery." Behavior Research and
Therapy, 1975, 13: 1 41 -52.
DuPont, R. L. Phobia: A Comprehensive Summary of Modern Treatments. New
York: Brunner/Mazel, 1982.
Mavissakalian, M., and D. H. Barlow. Phobia: Psychological and
Pharmacological Treatment. New York: Guildford Press, 1981.
Rachman, S. J. Fear and Courage. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman and
Company, 1978.
About the Author
M. Gawain Wells, a native of St. George, Utah, is an associate professor of
psychology and serves in the Comprehensive Clinic at Brigham Young University.
He has published articles on children's feelings and has done research on
religion and mental health. He has designed a diagnostic system for crisis
intervention. He and his wife Gayle, are rearing six children. Brother Wells has
served in the Church as a high councilor, as a bishop, and in many teaching and
administrative assignments.
|
|